Previously I’d done some sums that calculated my alloy race Caterham radiator could only cool a 4.0 (4031cc) V8. I was therefore fairly worried my 4.6Ltr Rover V8 would overheat. As these engines are famous for their overheating issues, I’ve added a second Radiator fan.
How to improve your cooling system
There is a lot talked about all the improvements you can make to stop a car over-heating. I’ve read dozens of articles. Some are very technical, comparing laminar flow to turbulent flow and various arguments are very hotly debated, so I decided to do some simple measurements using a few cheap tools.
I boiled a kettle, plugged up the radiator hoses and measured how long it took for water to drop from 60°C to 20°C. The reason I didn’t pick 100°C was because it took time for the radiator fins to heat up and stabilise. Without a fan it took approximately 190 seconds to drop 40°C. It was approximately 14°C in the workshop.
I now have two 12v slimline fans
|Power Supply:||12v DC, 7A, 80w|
|Air Flow Rate:||1130 cbm/hr, 2150cfm|
When I held the first fan against the radiator, without a fan shroud, the air-flow was barely noticeable. After straightening all the radiator fins, the air flow was slightly better, but still not as high as I expected.
I used a cheap anemometer and a simple sum to get Mass Air Flow. You can’t just stick one of these in front of a fan as air speed and mass would be different across the length of the blades. Therefore I made a 3 foot long cardboard tube, slightly funnelled to get an average turbulent flow.
m = ρ*V*A
m = Mass flow rate
ρ = Density of the liquid or gas(kg/m3) – 1.225,
V = Velocity of the liquid or gas(m/s)
A = Flow Area of the Liquid or gas(cm2) – 706.85834715
One Fan – No Radiator
Without a radiator interrupting flow, a 12″ 80watt curved blade fan moved air very quickly.
If you put your face in front of one of these 12″ fans, it’s like sticking your head out the car window on a motorway. Put a radiator in the way and the air flow is similar to opening the window whilst parked.
One Fan, A Radiator a no Fan Shroud
The radiator dropped the air Velocity considerably. Without a shroud it was obvious air was going in all directions apart from through the radiator. In fact 87% of the air mass (m) didn’t go through the radiator!
|Direction||V (m/S)||m||60°C to 20°C|
One Fan, A radiator & a Fan Shroud
I’d made sure that the shroud was sealed air tight to the radiator with silicon rubber edging. Without the edging you could hear the air whistle through the tiny gaps and clearly the air would rather escape sideways than pass straight through the radiator.
With the fan shroud, air speed was clearly up. But what was really incredible was the speed the water now cooled. To get the same 40°C temperature drop took 1/3rd the time. I wasn’t expecting that sort of improvement!
|Direction||V (m/S)||m||60°C to 20°C|
The first fan I fitted, was sucking air through the radiator from behind. The fan didn’t seem to perform quite so well sucking as blowing, so I checked to see if there was enough room to mount a fan in front of the radiator and blow. If I made another fan shroud 8mm shallower, then yes.
A sucking fan would be behind the radiator, this would not restrict the incoming flow when turned off.
Twin Fans with Shrouds
Now, having two fan shrouds, I bought a second fan and mounted them both. One pushing air, the other blowing. As you’d expect, with double the fan power, the improvements were far more significant than making sure the shrouds were air tight.
Two fans now pushed air close to the velocity of one uninhibited by a radiator. The air flow with two fans didn’t just flutter a rag, it blew tools off the bench! As you turn the second fan on, you can hear the first fan accelerate as well, making both fans perform better.
|Direction||V (m/S)||m||60°C to 20°C|
|Sucking & Blowing||3.3m/S||2857.47||21 secs|
The noise of air blasting through the radiator is very noticeable. I’m hoping that when mounted in the car, the engine will drown it and the bodywork will muffle it.The weight increase may have been a problem if I was building an ultra light racer, but this is a 300bhp V8 4×4 with custom bodywork.
Using the crude equation, from an ancient car mag, I found I needed to make similar air flow improvements a spacious engine compartment would bring. My radiator was close to being big enough but still inadequate.
With two 12″ radiator fans, a large oil cooler and 7″ Fans, I’m confident that air into the engine bay is about as good as it will ever be. I now have concerns that the super snug engine compartment will prevent the air from exiting smoothly.
Oil Cooler Fan
Originally I had the oil cooler behind the radiator with the fan sucking air and directing it towards the engine. I’ve moved it to the side of the engine compartment blowing air out of the engine bay. I have another 7″ fan for the other side too. The combination of fans pull air in, then push it back out.
I’m going to heat wrap the exhausts, but I’m also going to scoop outside air in from both sides of the engine compartment and funnel that over the exhausts.
|Diameter blade to blade||7″|
|CFM ratio||1550 cfm|
|Maximum fan CFM:||1,730 cfm|
|Maximum fan RPM:||2,250 rpm|
|Amp draw:||12.70 amps|
|Overall Size:||H : 220mm W : 245mm|
When I start the bodywork, I will construct another shroud to make sure all air entering the front grill is funnelled to the radiator. The simple edge sealant trick, proved that even when assisted by a fan, air would rather take any path than pass through a radiator. Anything than can be done to force air to take radiator route should help my cooling worries.
Without measuring a similar set-up I’m about as confident as I can be. The air flow is definitely on par if not significantly more than the viscous fan fitted to Rover SD1’s.
Do Multiple Radiator Fans cool better than one?
Although I did a few sums, it was the measurements that proved more air flow does, in my situation, improve cooling dramatically.
Getting that air flow is down to two things. Most importantly it’s down to directing air through the radiator and not allowing it to pass around the sides.
Is Fast Air Flow better than Slow?
In my set-up, I proved that making the air flow faster also increased the Mass of Air passing through the radiator. Doubling the air speed produced a 83% Air Mass increase and a 35% reduction in cooling time.
What would be interesting to test, given a radiator wide enough, is whether 2 side by side fans cooled better or worse than the same fans sucking and blowing from opposite sides. This would give a correlation between mass of air and speed of air. Is a high Mass Air flow but slow air speed better or worse than fast air but low Mass Air Flow? I suspect Mass of Air is the key, If the mass is the same, cooling rate would be the same. However, depending on the set-up, getting that extra Mass may require higher air speed. – but who knows without testing.
This is my theory….
If air within the engine bay was trapped, near the exhausts would become super heated, whilst air away from the engine would stay cooler. Circulating air (turbulent flow) would even the temperature distribution but ultimately the same amount of trapped heat energy would remain. If the air wasn’t trapped and changed on a constant basis that energy could be dispersed outside the engine bay. The Mass of Air would enable better dissipation.
With engine cooling, it is not only important that air cools the water in the radiator, it is also important that air passing over the engine, in particular the exhausts, isn’t already hot. Static air would simply heat up to the same temperature as the engine and give no cooling benefits. A high turn-over of air ensures surface cooling of the engine and exhausts. Slow air flow would firstly get heated passing through the radiator then again by the engine.
Other Flow restrictions & considerations
If the radiator was crammed up right to the engine there would be another flow restriction. It is important to have low pressure air behind the radiator. An under-tray between the radiator and engine could help with this.
Exhausts without heat shrouds will dissipate heat into the engine bay and not along the length of the car.
When engine run efficiently they also run cooler. Retarding ignition timing begins the combustion process later in the cycle and makes heat, therefore advancing timing can reduce heat.
A thin radiator with a large surface area is going to cool better than a small thick one with the same capacity.
Importance of a Fan Shroud
A simple fan shroud, doesn’t weigh much and doesn’t draw huge amounts of power. At cruising speed, ensuring all air through the grill passes through the radiator does far more than a fan.
Whilst stationary, a thermostat controlled fan is vital. If you’ve ever owned a vintage car, you’ll know that cars don’t run too well from cold, with the top speed halved. Getting to temperature quickly not only reduces wear it helps performance. As a car overheats, it slows down and begin to rattle.
A second fan does indeed speed up cooling, however the relationship between air mass and cooling times are non linear. Therefore the improvements from each additional fan are diminished.
A single fan knocked 153 seconds of the cooling time. A second fan only knocked a further 17 seconds off. However at high temperatures that difference may be essential.
On start up the fans seemed to draw huge amounts of current. My ammeter only measured up to 20Amps, but I’m suspecting current draw on start up could be close to 80Amps. It takes almost 15seconds for the current to drop to ~10amps. The 7Amps quoted by the manufacturer seems a little optimistic. If you have multiple fans it makes sense to stager the temperature they kick in at, otherwise you’ll be looking at misfires. 2 Fans take similar current to a starter motor.
To offset the massive start-up current draws, I’m using 2 different fan switches. 79°C / 88°C (INTERA033866). and 76°C / 86°C (50250). Hopefully those 3°C offset start-up by several seconds. Blow @ 76°C, suck at 79°C. I have an 80°C water thermostat.
With two fans I might have to upgrade my 80amp alternator. I’ll also have to make sure all the fan wires are short and thick.
Hopefully the air under the bonnet will be pretty turbulent as the temperature across the engine bay will be more constant.